# Tag Info

4

Yes, the two update equations are equivalent. As an aside, technically the equation you give is not the Bellman equation, but the update step re-written as an equation - in the Bellman equation instead of $v_{k+1}(s)$ or $v_{k}(s)$ (showing iterations of approximate value functions), you would have $v_{\pi}(s)$ (representing the true value of a state under ...

3

There is one thing I don't particularly understand. Why do we need the state-transition probability function when calculating the importance sampling ratio for off-policy prediction? It is not needed for calculation. It must be included in the theory, to compare the correct probability of each trajectory (on-policy vs off-policy). However, the state ...

2

The term you're looking for is "replacement schemes". As far as I'm aware, the primary reference on this is still Replacement Schemes for Transposition Tables, although it is a fairly old paper from 1994. I'll very briefly summarize the seven different schemes listed in this paper, but full text of the paper is also freely available and contains more info: ...

1

The core problem here is state representation, not estimating return due to delayed response to actions on the original state representation (which is no longer complete for the new problem). If you fix that, then you can solve your problem as a normal MDP, and base calculations on single timesteps. This allows you to continue using dynamic programming to ...

1

A full Bellman update can be intractable. For instance, if your state space or action space are continuous, the full Bellman update is intractable. You can try to solve this by discretizing, but if your state space is large this will also be intractable.

Only top voted, non community-wiki answers of a minimum length are eligible