Skip to main content
Commonmark migration
Source Link

AI is internally limited by model and externally limited by the environment.

Humans are externally limited by the environment but not necessarily internally limited by a computable model (as AI is).

So, humans may possess certain skills (e.g. creativity) that an AI may never possess. I had previously asked a related question https://ai.stackexchange.com/q/10139/2444.

Which research work supports my claims?

Brian Cantwell Smith says that there is no computation without representation (a model).

In the article The Brain Is Not Computable, Miguel Nicolelis, a top neuroscientist at Duke University, also says

The brain is not computable and no engineering can reproduce it

 

You can't predict whether the stock market will go up or down because you can’t compute it.

 

You could have all the computer chips ever in the world and you won't create a consciousness.

 

That's because its most important features are the result of unpredictable, nonlinear interactions among billions of cells

AI is internally limited by model and externally limited by the environment.

Humans are externally limited by the environment but not necessarily internally limited by a computable model (as AI is).

So, humans may possess certain skills (e.g. creativity) that an AI may never possess. I had previously asked a related question https://ai.stackexchange.com/q/10139/2444.

Which research work supports my claims?

Brian Cantwell Smith says that there is no computation without representation (a model).

In the article The Brain Is Not Computable, Miguel Nicolelis, a top neuroscientist at Duke University, also says

The brain is not computable and no engineering can reproduce it

 

You can't predict whether the stock market will go up or down because you can’t compute it.

 

You could have all the computer chips ever in the world and you won't create a consciousness.

 

That's because its most important features are the result of unpredictable, nonlinear interactions among billions of cells

AI is internally limited by model and externally limited by the environment.

Humans are externally limited by the environment but not necessarily internally limited by a computable model (as AI is).

So, humans may possess certain skills (e.g. creativity) that an AI may never possess. I had previously asked a related question https://ai.stackexchange.com/q/10139/2444.

Which research work supports my claims?

Brian Cantwell Smith says that there is no computation without representation (a model).

In the article The Brain Is Not Computable, Miguel Nicolelis, a top neuroscientist at Duke University, also says

The brain is not computable and no engineering can reproduce it

You can't predict whether the stock market will go up or down because you can’t compute it.

You could have all the computer chips ever in the world and you won't create a consciousness.

That's because its most important features are the result of unpredictable, nonlinear interactions among billions of cells

deleted 481 characters in body
Source Link
nbro
  • 41.4k
  • 12
  • 114
  • 205

AI are "internally limited" byis internally limited by model and "externally limited"externally limited by the environment.

but humans are "externally limited"Humans are externally limited by environment"the environment but not necessally "internally limited"not necessarily internally limited by a computable model as AI are

that skill make all the difference for an human-like AI system , AGI , Strong(as AI ..is).

for the rest neuroscience can helpSo, humans may possess certain skills (e.g. creativity) that an AI may never possess. I had previously asked a related question https://ai.stackexchange.com/q/10139/2444.

Edit to answer to comment :Which research work supports my claims?

Which research work supports your claims? Brian Cantwell Smith says that there is no computation without representation (a model).

  • about AI : ""no computation wihtout representation"" as seen upper with Brian Cantwell Smith

  • about neuroscience : see Miguel Nicolelis, work :

In the article The Brain Is Not Computable, Miguel Nicolelis, a top neuroscientist at Duke University, also says

"TheThe brain is not computable and no engineering can reproduce it, says Miguel Nicolelis

“You can’tYou can't predict whether the stock market will go up or down because you can’t compute it,” he says.

“YouYou could have all the computer chips ever in the world and you won’twon't create a consciousness.

That’sThat's because its most important features are the result of unpredictable, nonlinear interactions among billions of cells, Nicolelis says.

How can neuroscience help?

The framework given by the stream direction of research in neuroscience leads to mainstream as Cognitivisme or Computationalism in AI research. Neuroscience paradigm model impacts on ai research.

What do you mean by "that skill make all the difference for an human-like AI system , AGI , Strong AI ..."?

intuition, creativity, imagination

see ..https://ai.stackexchange.com/questions/10139/are-human-brain-processes-like-creativity-intuition-or-imagination-computable

AI are "internally limited" by model and "externally limited" by environment

but humans are "externally limited" by environment" but not necessally "internally limited" by computable model as AI are

that skill make all the difference for an human-like AI system , AGI , Strong AI ...

for the rest neuroscience can help....

Edit to answer to comment :

Which research work supports your claims?

  • about AI : ""no computation wihtout representation"" as seen upper with Brian Cantwell Smith

  • about neuroscience : see Miguel Nicolelis, work :

"The brain is not computable and no engineering can reproduce it, says Miguel Nicolelis

“You can’t predict whether the stock market will go up or down because you can’t compute it,” he says.

“You could have all the computer chips ever in the world and you won’t create a consciousness.

That’s because its most important features are the result of unpredictable, nonlinear interactions among billions of cells, Nicolelis says.

How can neuroscience help?

The framework given by the stream direction of research in neuroscience leads to mainstream as Cognitivisme or Computationalism in AI research. Neuroscience paradigm model impacts on ai research.

What do you mean by "that skill make all the difference for an human-like AI system , AGI , Strong AI ..."?

intuition, creativity, imagination

see ..https://ai.stackexchange.com/questions/10139/are-human-brain-processes-like-creativity-intuition-or-imagination-computable

AI is internally limited by model and externally limited by the environment.

Humans are externally limited by the environment but not necessarily internally limited by a computable model (as AI is).

So, humans may possess certain skills (e.g. creativity) that an AI may never possess. I had previously asked a related question https://ai.stackexchange.com/q/10139/2444.

Which research work supports my claims?

Brian Cantwell Smith says that there is no computation without representation (a model).

In the article The Brain Is Not Computable, Miguel Nicolelis, a top neuroscientist at Duke University, also says

The brain is not computable and no engineering can reproduce it

You can't predict whether the stock market will go up or down because you can’t compute it.

You could have all the computer chips ever in the world and you won't create a consciousness.

That's because its most important features are the result of unpredictable, nonlinear interactions among billions of cells

edit to best formatage and to answer to comment
Source Link

AI are ""internally "internally limited" by model"model and ""externally"externally limited" by environment""environment

but humans are ""externally"externally limited" by environment""environment" but not necessally ""internally"internally limited" by computable model""model as AI are

that skill make all the difference for an human-like AI system , AGI , Strong AI ...

for the rest neuroscience can help....

Edit to answer to comment :

Which research work supports your claims?

  • about AI : ""no computation wihtout representation"" as seen upper with Brian Cantwell Smith

  • about neuroscience : see Miguel Nicolelis, work :

"The brain is not computable and no engineering can reproduce it, says Miguel Nicolelis

“You can’t predict whether the stock market will go up or down because you can’t compute it,” he says.

“You could have all the computer chips ever in the world and you won’t create a consciousness.”

That’s because its most important features are the result of unpredictable, nonlinear interactions among billions of cells, Nicolelis says.

How can neuroscience help?

The framework given by the stream direction of research in neuroscience leads to mainstream as Cognitivisme or Computationalism in AI research. Neuroscience paradigm model impacts on ai research.

What do you mean by "that skill make all the difference for an human-like AI system , AGI , Strong AI ..."?

intuition, creativity, imagination

see ..https://ai.stackexchange.com/questions/10139/are-human-brain-processes-like-creativity-intuition-or-imagination-computable

AI are ""internally limited" by model" and ""externally limited" by environment""

but humans are ""externally limited" by environment"" but not necessally ""internally limited" by computable model"" as AI are

that skill make all the difference for an human-like AI system , AGI , Strong AI ...

for the rest neuroscience can help....

AI are "internally limited" by model and "externally limited" by environment

but humans are "externally limited" by environment" but not necessally "internally limited" by computable model as AI are

that skill make all the difference for an human-like AI system , AGI , Strong AI ...

for the rest neuroscience can help....

Edit to answer to comment :

Which research work supports your claims?

  • about AI : ""no computation wihtout representation"" as seen upper with Brian Cantwell Smith

  • about neuroscience : see Miguel Nicolelis, work :

"The brain is not computable and no engineering can reproduce it, says Miguel Nicolelis

“You can’t predict whether the stock market will go up or down because you can’t compute it,” he says.

“You could have all the computer chips ever in the world and you won’t create a consciousness.”

That’s because its most important features are the result of unpredictable, nonlinear interactions among billions of cells, Nicolelis says.

How can neuroscience help?

The framework given by the stream direction of research in neuroscience leads to mainstream as Cognitivisme or Computationalism in AI research. Neuroscience paradigm model impacts on ai research.

What do you mean by "that skill make all the difference for an human-like AI system , AGI , Strong AI ..."?

intuition, creativity, imagination

see ..https://ai.stackexchange.com/questions/10139/are-human-brain-processes-like-creativity-intuition-or-imagination-computable

Source Link
Loading